|
Flow Cytometry is
generally understood to provide recognition of biomarkers (proteins,
genes, small molecules) in individual cells on the basis of optical
detection of stimulated emission from fluorescent tags bound to
affinity products (antibodies, oligonucleotides, aptamers) that bind to
the biomarkers. Indeed, Fluorescence Activated Cell Sorting, FACS,
explicitly recognizes that fluorophores are innate to the method. The
majority of flow cytometers are used for analysis; a minority are used
for sorting intended to purify cell populations, and a subset of FACS
applications takes advantage of sorting for cell population
purification or so that the collected cells can be stripped and
re-labeled for subsequent complementary assay.
"If at first the idea is not absurd, then there
is no hope for it."
A. Einstein
Multiplex fluorescent assays in typical use are limited to about 4- or
5-plex due to overlap of the fluorescent signals, as shown below. There
are reports, and intense development, of higher-order multiplex
fluorescent assays (as many as 17 have been reported) through the use
of time-delayed excitation and detection, use of quantum dots in
combination with fluorophores and other means. Extension to more than,
say, 20-plex seems to be unlikely, and the practitioners generally
admit that more than 10-plex, possible on some commercial instruments,
requires heroic experimental design to account and correct for the
overlap.
|
| Overlay
of emission
spectra of 8 fluorophores (shaded) and 8 quantum dots (lines). The
substantial overlap into neighbor detection channels requires
significant, time-consuming and error-prone compensation. |
A new technology provides a transformative leap in
the capability of
quantitative massively multiplexed cell assay. Called Mass Cytometry,
it is premised on the use of elements, or stable isotopes, as tags
instead of fluorophores, with measurement of the tags using an
Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer (ICP-MS). The advantage
lies in the large number of available elements and stable isotopes
(potentially greater than 100), the high resolution of the mass
spectrometer between detection channels, and the large dynamic range
(linearity) of detection of the ICP-MS (9 orders of magnitude for
current commercial quadrupole-based systems for solution analysis).
|
| ICP-MS
spectra of 60
element isotopes. The high resolution of the detection channels and
large dynamic range eliminate the need for compensation, enabling
multiple parameter analysis with the ease of single channel assay.
|
These benefits, and others, result in the ability
to perform multiplex
assays of high order (as many as 100) without the need for mathematical
correction of overlap, and with large dynamic range both for a given
target biomarker and between different biomarkers (where, for instance,
neighbor detection channels can clearly distinguish antigens that
differ in concentration by up to 6 orders of magnitude, for solution
asays).
Other benefits
are high sensitivity (comparable to radioimmunoassay and
chemiluminescent assay; of the order of attomoles/microlitre or as
little as 100 copies of an antigen per cell); insensitivity to light or
time (so that the experiments can be performed in a lighted laboratory,
and can use reagents prepared or purchased long before --- unlike
fluorophores) ; and stability of the immunolabeled samples so that the
product can be stored and/or shipped for analysis (fluorophore activity
rapidly decreases with time).
Because many
thousands of distinguishable beads can be produced with the
incorporation of multiple elements as a barcode, a massively
multiplexed bead assay is enabled. Polystyrene beads are prepared to
incorporate a specified amount of several elements, which are trapped
inside the beads by chelation to prevent element leaching. The surface
of the beads is functionalized with amino or carboxyl groups for
convenient attachment of biomolecules (oligos, antibodies, etc). The
elemental encoding of the bead can indicate the type of biomolecule
that is attached, and hence the antigen or gene that it targets, or can
correspond with a sample identifier. In most instances, binding of the
target is flagged by a common reporter elemental tag that is sandwiched
to the antigen or functionalized to the gene. Hence, for example,
analysis at a rate of 1000 antisense-oligo-functionalized beads per
second provides a 1000 gene assay that can be conducted with 30-fold
redundancy in 30 seconds.
In addition, the
new class of metalopolymer tags is also suitable for determination
using conventional ICP-MS instruments in the instance that an average
assay over a sample ensemble (i.e., solution assay) is desired. For
example, where a tissue is sufficiently homogeneous, or the diagnostic
allows for averaging over the biopsy, the sample may be stained with
the metal-tagged antibodies and, following washing, may be acidified to
lyse the cells and provide a homogeneous solution that can be analyzed
according to long-standing standard ICP-MS protocols. The solution
assay protocols still allow for massively multiplexed assay, with
detection limits for each marker comparable to individual
radio-immunoassay.
|